• Login
  • Contact
  • About
    • Objectives
    • Organization
    • People
    • Partners
    • Job opportunities
    • Annual reports
    • Women in Finance
  • Research
    • Academic Seminars
    • Publications
    • Research in the spotlight
    • Disclosure policy
  • National PhD program
    • Core courses
    • Mini courses
    • PhD visitor program
    • National PhD conferences
    • PhD Seminars
    • Job market candidates
    • PhD Placements
  • Outreach
    • Academic seminars
    • Conferences
    • Industry seminars
    • Videos
    • Podcasts
    • News & press
      • News
      • In the press
      • Newsletters
    • Data Visualizations
  • Data Center
    • SHoF Data center – a national mission
    • Fama French Factors
    • FinBas
    • Historical Archives
    • NASDAQ HFT
    • Nordic Compass, SHoF's ESG Database
    • PAtLink
    • Serrano
    • SHoF Fund Data Morningstar
    • News
  • About
    • Objectives
      • Our guiding principles
    • Organization
      • Board
      • Management committee
      • SHoF advisory board
      • Scientific advisory board
      • Department of Finance SSE
    • People
      • Resident researchers
      • Academic partner visitors
      • Affiliated researchers
      • Postdoctoral fellows
      • Research assistants
      • Job market candidates
      • PhD students
      • Admininistration
      • Outreach
      • Data center
      • Advisors
    • Partners
      • Academic partners
      • Partners
    • Job opportunities
    • Annual reports
    • Women in Finance
      • Events
      • Videos & podcasts
      • Featured research
      • News & press
      • Women in Finance Data
  • Research
    • Academic Seminars
    • Publications
    • Research in the spotlight
    • Disclosure policy
  • National PhD program
    • Core courses
    • Mini courses
    • PhD visitor program
    • National PhD conferences
    • PhD Seminars
    • Job market candidates
    • PhD Placements
  • Outreach
    • Academic seminars
    • Conferences
    • Industry seminars
    • Videos
      • Interviews by Swedish House of Finance
      • SNS/SHoF Finance panels videos
      • Seminar videos
      • Conference videos
      • Annual Conference videos
    • Podcasts
    • News & press
      • News
      • In the press
      • Newsletters
    • Data Visualizations
      • The SUSY Monitor
      • Does Carbon Pricing Work? Evidence from Swedish Firms
      • Designing a Carbon Tax Policy That Works
      • Women in Finance Data
  • Data Center
    • SHoF Data center – a national mission
      • Terms and conditions
      • Academic advisory group
    • Fama French Factors
    • FinBas
      • Stocks Timeseries
      • Indices Timeseries
    • Historical Archives
      • Stocks list archive
      • Annual reports archive
      • Affärsvärlden Archive
      • Owners and Power
    • NASDAQ HFT
      • Reconstructed Order Book
      • Nordic Market Quality
    • Nordic Compass, SHoF's ESG Database
    • PAtLink
    • Serrano
    • SHoF Fund Data Morningstar
      • Valuations: Daily TNA and net flow by fund and fund share class
      • Re-invested Prices: Dividends re-invested prices
      • Splits: Fund split date and split ratio
      • Dividends: Fund dividends
      • Prices: Fund daily prices
    • News
  • Login
  • Contact
  • Swedish House of Finance
  • Outreach
  • News & press
  • News
  • “Dumb Money": Is the Rise of Passive Investing Always Good?
Swedish House of Finance
  • About
  • Research
  • National PhD program
  • Outreach
    • Academic seminars
    • Conferences
    • Industry seminars
    • Videos
    • Podcasts
    • News & press
      • News
      • In the press
      • Newsletters
    • Data Visualizations
  • Data Center

“Dumb Money": Is the Rise of Passive Investing Always Good?

okt. 15, 2024

The rise of passive investing has brought lower costs and better diversification for individual investors, but its broader impact on markets raises important concerns, according to insights shared at a recent Fireside Chat hosted by the Swedish House of Finance. Experts discussed the growing shift towards passive strategies and their potential long-term effects on financial markets.

The Fireside Chat with Paul Huebner took place on October 15, moderated by SHoF’s Alexander Ljungqvist and attended exclusively by SHoF partners and invited guests. Here's what they discussed:

Collateral Damage

One major issue highlighted was how passive investing disproportionately benefits large-cap firms, given their dominant presence in major indexes. Passive funds often track indexes like the S&P 100, which are heavily weighted toward large-cap companies, resulting in these firms receiving a larger share of capital inflows. This "overweighting" favors large-cap stocks, even though they are already substantial.

It was noted that it's more difficult to significantly increase positions in large-cap firms compared to smaller-cap stocks, which offer more flexibility. Consequently, large caps benefit more from inflows, while smaller-cap stocks may experience greater price movement during market shocks due to their flexibility.

Concerns were also raised about the widening gap between market valuations and fundamentals. The rise of benchmarking and "closet indexing" within active strategies was suggested as contributing to market inefficiencies. However, as passive investing grows, so too does the incentive for active investors to exploit these inefficiencies, potentially restoring balance to the market.

Corporate Governance Impact

The discussion also explored the potential impact of passive investing on corporate governance. Large passive shareholders tend not to actively monitor executives, which may reduce accountability and weaken board oversight. Some participants discussed the "common ownership hypothesis," where large asset managers holding stakes in competing companies could diminish competition in product markets, raising concerns for consumer welfare.

Less Can Be More in Regulation

Another key theme was the role of regulation in mitigating the risks of passive investing. It was suggested that reducing certain regulatory restrictions could enhance competition and market efficiency. On the other hand, measures like raising capital requirements or easing asset reporting thresholds might limit flexibility and weaken competition. Strengthening disclosure requirements was recommended as a way to improve transparency and address the risks of "closet indexing."

The discussion emphasized that the goal is not to limit passive investing but to improve the informational environment and bolster competition in financial markets.

Paul Huebner

Researcher, SHoF

Assistant Professor, Department of Finance, SSE

Read more

Alexander Ljungqvist

Researcher, SHoF

Professor, Stefan Persson Family Chair in Entrepreneurial Finance, Department of Finance, SSE

Read more

Passive Investing Is Reshaping the Stock Market—But Not Only for the Better

Read more

Meet Paul Huebner: Understanding the Competitiveness of Stock Markets

News 2024/04/09

Read more

  • About
    • Objectives
    • Organization
    • People
    • Partners
    • Job opportunities
    • Annual reports
    • Women in Finance
  • Research
    • Academic Seminars
    • Publications
    • Research in the spotlight
    • Disclosure policy
  • National PhD program
    • Core courses
    • Mini courses
    • PhD visitor program
    • National PhD conferences
    • PhD Seminars
    • Job market candidates
    • PhD Placements
  • Outreach
    • Academic seminars
    • Conferences
    • Industry seminars
    • Videos
    • Podcasts
    • News & press
      • News
      • In the press
      • Newsletters
    • Data Visualizations
  • Data Center
    • SHoF Data center – a national mission
    • Fama French Factors
    • FinBas
    • Historical Archives
    • NASDAQ HFT
    • Nordic Compass, SHoF's ESG Database
    • PAtLink
    • Serrano
    • SHoF Fund Data Morningstar
    • News

Swedish House of Finance

Bertil Ohlins gata 4, 113 50 Stockholm

info@houseoffinance.se +46 8 736 91 00
Subscribe