• Login
  • Contact
  • About
    • Objectives
    • Organization
    • People
    • Partners
    • Job opportunities
    • Annual reports
    • Women in Finance
  • Research
    • Academic Seminars
    • Publications
    • Research in the spotlight
    • Disclosure policy
  • National PhD program
    • Core courses
    • Mini courses
    • PhD visitor program
    • National PhD conferences
    • PhD Seminars
    • Job market candidates
    • PhD Placements
  • Outreach
    • Academic seminars
    • Conferences
    • Industry seminars
    • Videos
    • Podcasts
    • News & press
      • News
      • In the press
      • Newsletters
    • Data Visualizations
  • Data Center
    • SHoF Data center – a national mission
    • Fama French Factors
    • FinBas
    • Historical Archives
    • NASDAQ HFT
    • Nordic Compass, SHoF's ESG Database
    • PAtLink
    • Serrano
    • SHoF Fund Data Morningstar
    • News
  • About
    • Objectives
      • Our guiding principles
    • Organization
      • Board
      • Management committee
      • SHoF advisory board
      • Scientific advisory board
      • Department of Finance SSE
    • People
      • Resident researchers
      • Academic partner visitors
      • Affiliated researchers
      • Postdoctoral fellows
      • Research assistants
      • Job market candidates
      • PhD students
      • Admininistration
      • Outreach
      • Data center
      • Advisors
    • Partners
      • Academic partners
      • Partners
    • Job opportunities
    • Annual reports
    • Women in Finance
      • Events
      • Videos & podcasts
      • Featured research
      • News & press
      • Women in Finance Data
  • Research
    • Academic Seminars
    • Publications
    • Research in the spotlight
    • Disclosure policy
  • National PhD program
    • Core courses
    • Mini courses
    • PhD visitor program
    • National PhD conferences
    • PhD Seminars
    • Job market candidates
    • PhD Placements
  • Outreach
    • Academic seminars
    • Conferences
    • Industry seminars
    • Videos
      • Interviews by Swedish House of Finance
      • SNS/SHoF Finance panels videos
      • Seminar videos
      • Conference videos
      • Annual Conference videos
    • Podcasts
    • News & press
      • News
      • In the press
      • Newsletters
    • Data Visualizations
      • The SUSY Monitor
      • Does Carbon Pricing Work? Evidence from Swedish Firms
      • Designing a Carbon Tax Policy That Works
      • Women in Finance Data
  • Data Center
    • SHoF Data center – a national mission
      • Terms and conditions
      • Academic advisory group
    • Fama French Factors
    • FinBas
      • Stocks Timeseries
      • Indices Timeseries
    • Historical Archives
      • Stocks list archive
      • Annual reports archive
      • Affärsvärlden Archive
      • Owners and Power
    • NASDAQ HFT
      • Reconstructed Order Book
      • Nordic Market Quality
    • Nordic Compass, SHoF's ESG Database
    • PAtLink
    • Serrano
    • SHoF Fund Data Morningstar
      • Valuations: Daily TNA and net flow by fund and fund share class
      • Re-invested Prices: Dividends re-invested prices
      • Splits: Fund split date and split ratio
      • Dividends: Fund dividends
      • Prices: Fund daily prices
    • News
  • Login
  • Contact
  • Swedish House of Finance
  • Outreach
  • News & press
  • News
  • Analyzing two different ESG drivers: Investor preferences and sustainability ratings
Swedish House of Finance
  • About
  • Research
  • National PhD program
  • Outreach
    • Academic seminars
    • Conferences
    • Industry seminars
    • Videos
    • Podcasts
    • News & press
      • News
      • In the press
      • Newsletters
    • Data Visualizations
  • Data Center

Analyzing two different ESG drivers: Investor preferences and sustainability ratings

Article by Josephine Chennell

maj. 13, 2022

According to the UN Principles for Responsible Investment more than a third of the world’s investments are currently bound up in ESG related assets. The tools to advance sustainable investment within the broader Environment, Social and Governance (ESG) framework are many, but despite the recent rush to invest, an increasing number of critics suggest that the ESG concept is flawed, both with regard to achieving the promised planetary and social relief, and when it comes to delivering alpha returns to investors.

The challenge facing investors is a significant lack of transparency and standardisation regarding the underlying ESG criteria

As part of a broader global effort to colour in the ESG investment map with more detail, Mariassunta Giannetti, Professor of Finance at the Stockholm School of Economics, joined forces with research partners Nickolay Gantchev at the University of Warwick and Rachel Li, University of Alabama, to put the spotlight on two different ESG investment drivers, namely market discipline and sustainability ratings respectively in two new studies.

The first study Does Money Talk? Market Discipline through Sell-offs and Boycotts proves that while shareholders, even small ones, can play a powerful role in putting pressure on companies to advance their ESG policies through market discipline, especially in countries where the culture and regulatory conditions support responsible investment, it still suggests that a more standardized regulation will likely be needed in order to effectively accelerate and advance material ESG impact.

The second study Sustainability or Performance? Ratings and Fund Managers’ Incentives, analyzed the short and longer term performance of Morningstar's sustainability rating, the Globe Rating, introduced in 2010. The study shows how and why the Globe Rating, which was offered to investors in parallel with Morningstar’s original performance rating, the Star Rating, over time became undermined, effectively rendering the sustainability rating unfit for purpose.

 

Learn more about the studies and their findings in a more detailed article here.

Mariassunta Giannetti

Researcher, SHoF

Katarina Martinson Professor of Finance, Department of Finance, SSE

Read more

The papers:

Does Money Talk? Market Discipline through sell-offs and boycotts

Sustainability or Performance? Ratings and Fund Managers’ Incentives

Sustainable Finance

Today, there is a great deal of activity underway to study aspects of sustainable finance and it has become an integral part of conventional fields of financial research. Rather than being an entirely new strand of research, sustainable finance has emerged as a natural application, in which researchers look at financial markets through a specific lens.

Here you can find research papers, events, news and videos within the field of Sustainable Finance

Read more

  • About
    • Objectives
    • Organization
    • People
    • Partners
    • Job opportunities
    • Annual reports
    • Women in Finance
  • Research
    • Academic Seminars
    • Publications
    • Research in the spotlight
    • Disclosure policy
  • National PhD program
    • Core courses
    • Mini courses
    • PhD visitor program
    • National PhD conferences
    • PhD Seminars
    • Job market candidates
    • PhD Placements
  • Outreach
    • Academic seminars
    • Conferences
    • Industry seminars
    • Videos
    • Podcasts
    • News & press
      • News
      • In the press
      • Newsletters
    • Data Visualizations
  • Data Center
    • SHoF Data center – a national mission
    • Fama French Factors
    • FinBas
    • Historical Archives
    • NASDAQ HFT
    • Nordic Compass, SHoF's ESG Database
    • PAtLink
    • Serrano
    • SHoF Fund Data Morningstar
    • News

Swedish House of Finance

Bertil Ohlins gata 4, 113 50 Stockholm

info@houseoffinance.se +46 8 736 91 00
Subscribe