This website uses cookies. By using this website you are agreeing to our use of cookies and to the terms and conditions listed in our data protection policy. Read more

I agree
Stockholm school
of economics
  • Education
  • Research
  • Outreach
  • Library
  • About us
  • Svenska
  • Login
  • Contact
  • Education
    • Bachelor Programs
      • Business and Economics
        • Program Description
        • Application & Admission
        • Student & Alumni Stories
        • FAQ
      • Retail Management
        • Program Description
        • Application & Admission
        • Student & Alumni Stories
        • FAQ
    • Master Programs
      • International Business
        • Program Description
        • Application & Admission
        • Student & Alumni Stories
      • Business & Management
        • Program Description
        • Application & Admission
        • Student & Alumni Stories
      • Finance
        • Program Description
        • Application & Admission
        • Student & Alumni Stories
        • Double Degree
      • Economics
        • Program Description
        • Application & Admission
        • Student & Alumni Stories
        • Double Degree
      • Accounting, Valuation & Financial Management
        • Program Description
        • Application & Admission
        • Student & Alumni Stories
      • Double Degree
      • Previous Programs
        • General Management
        • Management
        • Marketing & Media Management
    • PhD Programs
      • Business Administration
        • Program Description
        • Application & Admission
        • Student & Alumni Stories
      • Economics
        • Program Description
        • Application & Admission
        • Student & Alumni Stories
      • Finance
        • Program Description
        • Application & Admission
        • Student & Alumni Stories
    • MBA
      • This is our MBA
        • Upcoming start
        • Program Modules and Courses
          • Concentration Innovation & Entrepreneurship
          • Concentration Financial Management
        • Participant Profile
        • Individual Coaching
        • Learning Philosophy
        • MBALive®
        • International field trips
      • SSE MBA at a Glance
      • Your application
        • Tuition fee and payment structure
        • Present your business case
        • Benefits for the employer
      • Faculty, Advisory Board, Program Team
        • SSE MBA Faculty
        • SSE MBA Advisory board
        • SSE MBA Program Team
      • Voices of the program
        • Johan Berglund
        • Jenny Lantz
        • Mariette Kristenson
        • Carl Thorfinn
        • Mikael Runsiö
        • Södra
        • Ulrika Martinius
        • Charlotta Eriksson
      • Scholarships
      • SSE MBA Movies
      • Articles
      • Contact
      • FAQ
    • Executive Education
      • SSE Executive Education
      • SSE Riga Executive Education
      • SSE Russia - Executive MBA
      • Hanken & SSE Executive Education
    • Study at SSE
      • Welcome to SSE
      • Global Opportunities
        • Double Degree
        • Student Exchange
        • CEMS
        • GELS Scholarship
          • FAQ
        • K-A Bonnier International Fellows Program
        • Wallenberg International Fellows Program
        • The Swedish Program
        • The Short Program
      • Tuition and Scholarships
      • Tests that we accept
      • Study in Stockholm
      • Student Life
        • The Introductions
        • Student clubs & activities
        • Sports, trips & tournaments
        • Career opportunities
        • Go international
        • Traditions & festivities
        • Inspirational lectures & workshops
        • Your voice matters
      • Student Association
      • Student Ambassadors
      • Housing
        • Pontonjärgatan
        • Saltmätargatan
        • Lappkärrsberget
        • Högbergsgatan
        • Liljeholmen
        • Huvudsta
        • Mälarterrassen
        • Contact
      • Student Handbook & Grading
      • After Graduation
      • Podcasts
      • Meet Us
  • Research
    • Departments
      • Department of Accounting
        • Research
          • Peer Reviewed Research Articles
          • Books and Book Chapters
          • Ongoing PhD-projects
        • Courses in the Bachelor Programs at SSE
        • Master in Accounting, Valuation & Financial Management
        • PhD in Accounting and Financial Management
          • PhD Program in Business Administration
          • The Research School in Accounting - FIRE
        • People
        • History
        • News
        • Seminars
        • Contact
      • Department of Economics
        • People
        • Bachelor & Master Courses
        • PhD Program
        • Research
        • Seminar in Economics
        • Lunch Seminars
        • Dissertations
        • Job Market Candidates
        • Ohlin Lectures
          • Previous Years
        • Mini Courses
      • Department of Entrepreneurship, Innovation & Technology
      • Department of Finance
        • People
          • Faculty
          • PhD Students
          • Staff
        • Bachelor Program
        • Master Program
        • PhD Program
          • Dissertations
          • Former PhD Students
          • Mini Courses
          • Workshops
          • PhD Seminars, Swedish House of Finance
        • Seminars
        • Vacancies
        • Job Market Candidates
        • Swedish House of Finance
      • Department of Law, Languages and Economic Statistics
      • Department of Management and Organization
        • Research
          • Research areas
          • Projects and Programs
          • Completed Projects and Programs
        • Education
        • Publications
          • Books
          • Book chapters
          • Journal articles
        • People
      • Department of Marketing and Strategy
        • Research
        • Available Books
        • History
        • People
          • In Memoriam
        • Courses
        • Social Media
        • Contact
    • Centers
      • Accounting and Managerial Finance
      • Arts, Business & Culture
        • Current and Recent Research Projects
        • People
        • Publications
          • Books and Doctoral Dissertations
          • Peer Reviewed Research Articles
          • Book Chapters
          • Conference Presentations
          • Reports
        • Events
      • Business Law
        • Courses
        • Libraries
        • Affiliated Organizations
          • Handelsrättsligt Forum
          • Mercurius Förlags AB
          • Stiftelsen MercurIUS
        • People
        • Links
      • Stockholm Center for Civil Society Studies
        • Research
          • The Nonprofit Sector
          • Foundations
          • Co-operatives
          • Membership
        • People
          • Lisa Maria Dellmuth
          • Stefan Einarsson
          • Torbjörn Einarsson
          • David Falk
          • Martin Gustavsson
          • Ebba Henrekson
          • Curt-Olof Mann
          • Marta Reuter
          • Erik Sjöstrand
          • Filip Wijkström
          • Fredrik O Andersson
          • Jan Ström
          • Katarina Friberg
          • Maria Grafström
          • Tino Schöllhorn
          • Anna Lundstedt
          • Susanne Wallman-Lundåsen
          • Pelle Åberg
        • Education
        • European Civil Society Press
          • ECSP publications
        • Seminars and Events
      • Consumer Marketing
        • About us
          • Nils-Erik Wirsäll
        • Consumer Knowledge
        • People
        • Contact
      • Center for Data Analytics
        • People
        • BSc and MSc courses
        • PhD Courses
        • Research
        • Seminars and workshops at CDA
        • News
        • Publications
        • Video Filmed mathematics lectures for new students
        • Useful links
        • Vacancies
        • Demos Data Analytics
        • Center for Forecasting and Data Analytics (CFDA)
      • Center for Digital Innovation and Transformation
        • Research
          • Digital Business Transformation and Structural Changes in the Networked Society
          • Digital Transformation Think Tank
          • Managing Digital Transformation – New SIR Book 2017
          • PhD projects
        • People
        • Publications
          • Digital Transformation
          • E-Business
          • Innovation
          • Mobility & NFC
          • Shaping Business
          • Technology and Industry Convergence
          • Other Research
          • Doctoral Dissertations
          • Industry Reports
        • Education
          • Managing Digital Transformation – Theory and Practice
          • Managing Digital Transformation in the Incumbent Firm
          • Strategic Thinking in a Global Digital World
          • Executive Education
          • Media Management (2003-2015)
          • Media Management Alumni
        • Contact
      • Entrepreneurship and Business Creation
        • Publications
          • Books, Chapters and Reports
          • Journal articles
        • Research
        • People
        • News
      • Center for Forecasting and Data Analytics
      • Governance and Management Studies
        • About the Center
        • People
        • Projects
          • Board Practice in Major Nordic Companies
          • Financialization and the New Swedish Model
          • From Industrial to Financial Capitalism
          • Governing Complex Co-operation. A Study of Swedish Corporatist Insurance Companies
          • Institutional investor corporate ownership
          • Institutional Analysis of Cross-border Hostile Takeovers
          • Institutionalization of Nomination Committees in Swedish Corporate Governance
          • Rethinking Corporate Governance
          • The Role of the Board in Non-Profit Organizations
        • Publications
        • News
        • Seminars and Events
        • Contact
      • House of Innovation
      • Swedish House of Finance
      • HRM and Knowledge Work
        • Research
          • Human Resource Management
          • Knowledge Work and Professional Services
          • Changing Organizations
        • People
        • Publications
          • Articles in scientific journals
          • Book chapters
          • Books
          • Student Thesis
        • Contact
      • Innovation and Operations Management
        • Contact
        • People
        • Projects
        • Publications
      • Legal Research
      • The Center for Market Studies
        • Ongoing research at The Center for Market Studies
        • People
        • Publications
          • Articles
          • Books
          • Book Chapters
          • Doctoral Dissertations
        • History
        • Contact
      • Media and Economic Psychology
        • People
        • Publications
          • Books, Chapters and Reports
          • Conferences and Proceedings
          • Dissertations
          • Journal articles
          • Other publications
        • Research
        • Seminars
        • News
      • Modern Languages
        • Courses
        • People
      • Stockholm Centre for Organizational Research
      • Research on Sustainable Markets
        • Current Research Projects
          • Urban sustainability, sustainably urban? The importance of interlocked markets to (un)sustainable outcomes in Stockholm and beyond
          • Sustainable Development Goals and Energy Use
          • Vinnova Green Finance
          • Sustainability & Financial Markets
          • Monetization of Circular Economy benefits in the fashion and clothing industry
          • Shared Value
          • Long-term investing and inclusive market economies
          • CRSM Researchers partially funded through Misum
          • The tourist industry and its contribution to sustainable development: Social networks and social capital in the employment of immigrants
        • CSRM Project Researchers
      • Center for Retailing
        • Mission
        • Bachelor in Retail Management
        • Applied Retail Track
          • Retail Club Activities
          • Partners
        • Research
        • News
        • People
        • Events
      • Center for Retail Studies
        • Researchers
        • CFR Research School in Retailing
          • Courses and Schedule
          • Eligibility
          • Application
          • Business Collaborations
          • Important dates
          • Alumni Network
          • Contact
      • Sports and Business
        • About Us
          • Research and Ongoing Projects
          • Swedish Alliance for Women in Sport
        • People
        • Contact
        • News
      • Strategy and Competitiveness
        • Research
          • Strategy and International Business
          • Knowledge in Networks
          • Clusters and Competitiveness
          • Competitiveness Policy
        • Publications
          • Articles and Book Chapters
          • Books and Reports
          • Presentations
          • CSC in media
          • Other reports with contributions
          • Links
        • People
          • Visiting Faculty & Previous Staff
        • Contact
    • Institutes
      • European Institute of Japanese Studies
        • 欧州日本研究所(日本語)
          • EIJSアカデミーセミナー
          • 研究活動
          • EJARN
          • スタッフ・顧問会・役員会
          • 歴史
          • お問い合わせ先
        • Research
          • EIJS, East Asian Economics and Business Series
          • Working Paper
          • Publications
        • Education
          • PhD Program
          • Courses
        • Resources
        • EJARN
          • EJARN Conference 2018
          • Activity
          • Members
        • Network
        • Recent Activities
        • Seminars
        • News
        • People
        • Board
          • Advisory Board
        • Contact
        • History
      • Center for Advanced Studies in Leadership
        • About us
          • Board and Funding Institutions
          • Contact us
        • CASL people
          • Meet faculty
        • Research areas
        • CASL in the press
        • News
        • Seminars
        • CASL impact
        • Publications
        • Leadership update
          • Editorial Team
          • Leadership update archive
        • Partners
      • Institute for Economic and Business History Research
        • People
          • Board
        • Research
          • Research Seminars
          • Symposium, September 13-14, 2018
          • Heckscher Lectures
          • Håkan Lindgren Prize
          • About EHFF
          • Courses given by EHFF
        • Publications
          • Research reports
          • Working papers
        • Partners and Journals
      • Stockholm School of Economics Institute for Research
        • Research Centers
        • The SIR Research Award
        • Seminars & Conferences
          • Previous Years
        • SIR Publications
          • SIR´s Yearbook 2017
          • SIR's Yearbook 2016
          • SIR's Yearbook 2015
        • About SIR
          • The Board
          • Administrative Office
          • Vacancies
        • Contact
        • Internal
          • Research funding and applications
          • Finance and travel
          • Library/IT/Support
      • Misum
        • About us
          • More about us
          • Misum Board
          • Press Contact
          • Find us
          • PRME
        • People
        • Misum Seed Funding
        • Misum Research
          • Sustainable Finance
          • Sustainable Socioeconomic Development
          • Innovating Markets
        • Misum Archive
          • Academic Publications
          • Misum Interviews
          • Misum in the media
          • Misum Podcasts
        • Event archive
          • Sustainable Finance Conference Aug 2018
          • Jeffrey Sachs
          • Kate Raworth
          • Sustainable Consumption
          • Cass Sunstein on Nudging
          • Green Finance
          • Misum/Mistra Financial Systems meets Harrison Hong
          • Misum och Naturskyddsföreningen seminarium
          • Nu kör vi mot 2030 - hur blir din affärsidé en vinnare?
          • Misum and Hybrid Talks
          • Från invandring till vinnvandring 22 mars
        • Events and Activities
        • News from Misum
        • Misum-röster om Nobelpriset i ekonomi
          • Max Jerneck fördjupning
        • Ny rapport: Ett Sverige där anställda äger
        • Research on Sustainability at SSE
          • Digital transformation and sustainability by Per Andersson
          • Good citizens by Wiley Wakeman
          • Homo Moralis by Jörgen Weibull and Ingela Alger
        • Call for papers: CSR communication and reporting in challenging times
      • Stockholm China Economic Research Institute
        • About Us
          • Statement from the Director
          • SCERI Board
        • Research
          • Working Paper Series
          • Financial Markets and Financial Integration
          • Financial Policies
          • Political Participation by Business Owners
        • Education
        • People
        • Seminars and Conferences
          • 2017 Conference
          • 2016 Conference
          • 2015 Conference
          • 2014 Conference
          • 2013 Conference
          • 2012 Conference
          • Lecture by Leif Johansson, Chairman of the Board of Ericsson, 8 April 2016
          • 2018 Conference
        • News
      • Stockholm Institute of Transition Economics
        • About us
          • Contact
          • History
          • Board and Funding
          • Sister Institutes
          • Social media
        • Events
        • News
        • People
          • Affiliated Faculty
        • Publications
    • Research Houses
      • House of Innovation
        • The House
        • The Research
          • The connected refugee and reconfigurings of the migration process
          • Digitalization in the Public Sector
          • Knowledge processes within technology-based strategic alliances
          • Innovation performance of new entrants in emerging technology fields
          • Digital Health Accounts
          • Internationalizing Swedish SMEs
          • Moral Licensing and Venture Capital
          • Evolution of Autonomous transportation systems
          • Design Thinking 4 Business
        • The Education
        • The People
        • Outreach & Impact
          • Past Events
          • Publications
          • Media
        • Our Upcoming Events
        • Our News
      • Swedish House of Finance
    • Dissertations
  • Outreach
    • Alumni and Friends
      • Upcoming Events
      • Reconnect with SSE
        • Homecoming 2019
        • Reunions
      • International Alumni Hubs
        • New York Alumni Hub
        • London Alumni Hub
        • Germany Alumni Hub
        • Hong Kong Alumni Hub
      • Support SSE
        • Annual Fund
        • American Friends of SSE Scholarship
        • Ways to Give
        • Official Alumni Associations
      • SSE Alumni Club
      • Contact Alumni Office
      • Update your Contact Information
    • Corporate Relations
      • Corporate Partnership Program
        • New concept Capital Partners
      • Advisory Board
      • Corporate Partners
      • Involvement in Education
      • Voices about the Corporate Partnership Program
      • Team Corporate Relations
      • Innovative and Sustainable Business Development
        • Professorship, Center and Research Program
        • Professor Sarah Jack
        • Outreach Program
        • Our Supporters
    • Career Management
      • Career Services for International students
      • Skills Courses
      • MSc Mentor Program
        • Mentee
        • Mentor
        • Contact us
    • SSE Initiatives
      • Global Challenges
        • Educational shift
        • Courses
        • Global Challenges Foundation
        • Advisory Board
      • SSE Gunnar Hedlund Award
        • Previous winners
      • SSE Art Initiative
        • Events and Exhibitions
          • Symposiums
          • Research Colloquia
          • Collection
          • Exhibitions
          • Screenings
          • Art Talks
          • Streaming Poetry
        • Calendar
        • About us
        • Visit us
        • The Board Room
        • The Heckscher-Ohlin Room
        • Sustainable Art
        • Ingmar Bergman's Grand Piano
      • SSE and the Nobel Prize
        • Award Ceremony Speech
      • RAMP
        • RAMP 2018/2019
        • Admission Criteria
        • Application Process
        • Important Dates
        • Information Meetings
        • Our Internship Companies
        • Voices of RAMP
        • Class of 2016/2017
          • Adel al Lulu
          • Afaaf Naddour
          • Ali Rajab
          • Azeb Samuel
          • Basem Alsalameh
          • Bisrat Zeleke
          • Housam Hallak
          • Hussam Alhumsi
          • Ibaa Halal
          • Jack Bandek
          • Lana Haddad
          • Majd Dagher
          • Negin Namazi
          • Rand Entabi
        • Contact Us
      • Female Economist of the Year
        • About the FEOY-scholarship
        • Press
        • Previous winners
        • Founder
        • Contact
      • SSE Business Lab
        • OFFICE SPACE
        • INCUBATE
          • Apply to INCUBATE
          • The Incubate Program
          • Professional Services Partners
          • Software & Tools Partners
          • Incubate Members
          • Incubate Alumni
        • INITIATE
        • People
        • Careers
        • GDPR
      • SSE Sisters
      • SSE Literary Agenda
        • Ännu ett liv – a review by Gillian Wong Miswardi
  • Library
    • Services
      • Borrowing
      • Consult a Librarian
      • Off Campus Access to e-Resources
      • Databases
      • E-Books
      • Reading Impediments
      • Suggest a Book for Acquisition
      • FAQ
    • News
    • SSE Publications
      • Licentiate Dissertations in Fulltext
      • Doctoral Dissertations in Fulltext
      • Working Paper Series
      • Master's Theses
      • Bachelor's Theses
  • About us
    • Organization
      • Board of Directors and International Advisory Council
      • Management
      • Stockholm School of Economics Association
      • Professional Services units
        • Academic Affairs
        • Academic Support & Records
        • External Relations
          • Career Management
          • Communications & Marketing
          • Corporate Relations
          • Alumni and Foundation Relations
          • Special Events
        • Quality Assurance
        • Office of Finance and Accounting
        • IT Services
        • Human resources
        • Program Office
        • Research Office
        • Services and Purchasing
      • Departments
      • Mission and Vision
      • Equality and Diversity
      • Sustainability at SSE
      • SSE in Print
    • History
      • Year by Year
      • 2019 - A year of celebrations
    • Accreditations and Rankings
      • International rankings
      • EQUIS
      • PRME
      • SSE Worldwide
    • Contact
      • Press Contact
        • Press Photos
        • Press Clips
      • School Visits
    • Work at SSE
    • Data Protection - GDPR
      • GDPR Forms
  • Svenska
  • Login
  • Contact
  • SSE
  • About us
  • News
  • SITE News
  • 2016
  • On the Timing of Turkey’s Authoritarian Turn
About us
  • Organization
  • History
  • Accreditations and Rankings
  • Contact
  • Work at SSE
  • Data Protection - GDPR

On the Timing of Turkey’s Authoritarian Turn

2016-04-09

New policy brief by Erik Meyersson, Assistant Professor at the Stockholm Institute of Transition Economics (SITE), examines the timing of Turkey’s authoritarian turn using raw data measuring freedoms from the Freedom House (FH).

This policy brief shows that Turkey’s authoritarian turn under the ruling AKP is not a recent phenomenon. Instead, the country’s institutional erosion – especially in terms of freedoms of expression and political pluralism – in fact began much earlier, and the losses in the earlier periods so far tend to dwarf those occurring later.

Introduction

A growing field in economics emphasizes the importance of the media in shaping economic outcomes. Whereas the role of the media in informing voters is well established (Strömberg, 2015), recent research also points to the link between the rise of illiberal democracies (Mukand and Rodrik, 2016) and authoritarian control over media (Guriev and Treisman, 2015).

In few countries is the link between authoritarianism and restrictions on freedom of expression as pervasive as in Turkey. The Turkish government under the Erdoğan-led Justice and Development Party AKP has gutted the judiciary of most of its independence, and set it loose to crack down on critical media. These dire circumstances, however, contrast markedly with descriptions of Turkey from of a few years ago. Quite recently many analysts still deemed Turkey a "vibrant democracy", and as late as in 2013 the foreign minister of Sweden proclaimed: "Erdoğan's Turkey is on the right path." This media shift raises concerns over the public portrayal of Turkey's institutional development up until the last few years as well as the extent to which analysts may have misinterpreted Turkey's institutional development over the past decade.

Measures of Freedoms

To this date, the most prominent source of measuring freedoms in the world is the Freedom House's annual Freedom of the World reports (Freedom House, 2015), which designates countries into one of three statuses: Free, Partly Free, and Not Free, in ascending order in freedoms. In constructing these statuses, FH uses subscores for 7 subcategories, aggregated into 2 categories -- Political Rights (hereby PR), with a range of 0 to 40 increasing in freedoms, and Civil Liberties (hereby CL), with a range 0 to 60 increasing in freedoms – for which each then gets its own 1-7 (with a low value indicating more freedoms and vice versa), and in turn these are used to classify a country as having a particular Freedom status. From the FH's methodology section:

A country or territory is awarded 0 to 4 points for each of 10 political rights indicators and 15 civil liberties indicators, which take the form of questions; a score of 0 represents the smallest degree of freedom and 4 the greatest degree of freedom. The political rights questions are grouped into three subcategories: Electoral Process (3 questions), Political Pluralism and Participation (4), and Functioning of Government (3). The civil liberties questions are grouped into four subcategories: Freedom of Expression and Belief (4 questions), Associational and Organizational Rights (3), Rule of Law (4), and Personal Autonomy and Individual Rights (4).

The PR category thus focuses more on rights pertaining to politics, and is used also to construct an indicator variable for whether a country constitutes an electoral democracy or not. CL, as the name indicates, is more focused on liberties, including the right to freedom of expression, including media freedoms.

Somewhat curiously, Turkey's ratings have barely budged over the last decade, and have been consistently classified as a Partly Free country. In 2005, FH assigned Turkey a 3 in both PR and CL, and the only change since then was a one-point drop in 2012's CL rating down to 4.

The PR and CL, as well as their subcategory, scores are available on FH's website. Using these, the graphs below plot the evolution of the PR and CL total scores for Turkey between 2005-2015 (which is the period for which FH provides this data), as well as the 25th, 50th, and 75th global percentiles from the annual world distribution of the respective scores. The latter allows gauging not just the absolute performance of Turkey but also that relative to the rest of the world.

Figure 1. Freedom House Category Scores

fig1

Note: The red lines in the upper (lower) graph indicate the Political Rights (Civil Liberties) score. The dashed gray lines indicate the 25th, 50th, and 75th percentiles.

Turkey's PR score (upper graph) is relatively flat over the decade with a 4-point drop after 2013, while the CL score (lower graph) has been falling since 2010 and was stagnant in the period before. Whereas Turkey started the period with a CL score just below the median country, it ended closer to the 25th percentile. None of the years show any indication of expanding freedoms during AKP's rule.

The disaggregation of these scores into subcategories sheds further light on which of the latter have driven the former. For Turkey, especially relevant subcategories are the political pluralism and freedom of expression. The former refers to the degree to which people can organize in political groupings, credible opportunities for a political opposition, freedom from outside interference, and political rights for ethnic minorities. (This has clear links with the political barriers to entry such as the ten-percent threshold, the banning of political parties, and the persecution of Kurdish political activists in Turkey.) The latter subcategory refers to freedoms related to media, culture, religion, and academics, as well as the degree of freedom from government surveillance. Turkey's subscores are plotted below, grouped by PR and CL:

Figure 2. Freedom House Subcategory Scores

fig2

In Figure 2, there is rather striking fall in both the political pluralism (red in upper graph) and freedom of expression (blue in lower graph). The other subscores tend to be more stagnant over time, and the only subcategory that exhibited any significant positive momentum during the period is Electoral Process, although by 2015 it had reverted to its 2005 value. The falls in political pluralism and freedom of expression are large in magnitude, from 12 to 9 in the former, and 12 to 8 in the latter. Taking the latter decrease at face value would imply that Turkish citizens in 2015 have two-thirds of the freedoms of expression that they enjoyed in 2005. Moreover, the clear majority of the falls in both these variables occured before 2013 – the post-2013 fall in freedom of expression accounts for only one fourth of the total fall observed since 2007.

Given the degree to which civil liberties have eroded faster than that of political rights in Turkey, this begs the question how its inherent degree of illiberalism has evolved relative to other democracies. For this purpose, I plot the Freedom of Expression subcategory (a part of the CL score) against the PR score for the 2015. This latter score is used by FH to classify countries into whether they can be called 'electoral democracies' or not (CL subcategories have no bearing on this classification):

"An 'electoral democracy' designation requires a score of 7 or better in subcategory A (Electoral Process) and an overall Political Rights score of 20 or better."

FH thus classifies Turkey as an electoral democracy - its Electoral Process is consistently above 7 (see upper graph in Figure 2) and PR score above 20 (see Figure 1). But are there many FH-classified electoral democracies with similar levels of freedom of expression? Figure 3 answers this question:
Figure 3. Freedom House Subcategory Scores

fig3

Note: Green = Autocracy, blue = Democracy, Red = Turkey. The dashed green/blue lines indicate the median values for autocracies/democracies.

In 2015, Turkey is much closer to the median autocracy than the median democracy in terms of freedom of expression. Numerous autocracies have higher levels of freedom of expression than Turkey, and only two other electoral democracies have lower values of this variable: Bangladesh and Pakistan.

Consequently, Turkey today is a clear outlier due to its freedom of expression deficit among the countries classified as electoral democracies by FH. Yet the slide in Turkeys' freedoms did not start in the last couple of years but has remained a pervasive feature of its institutional trajectory during the last decade.

Much of Turkey's erosion of freedoms would not be as visible using only the most aggregate seven-point scaled ratings, as these obfuscate important changes within the rating scores. A shift in analysts' focus to more disaggregated data may thus be useful in order to detect warning signs in a more timely fashion.

Finally, the severe deficit in freedoms in countries nonetheless classified by Freedom House as electoral democracies raises the issue of whether there should be a lower freedom bound to inclusion into the group of democracies in the world. And if so, what should determine such a lower bound?

References

  • Freedom House, 2016, "Freedom of the World 2016."
  • Guriev, Sergei, and Daniel Treisman, 2015, "How Modern Dictators Survive: An Informational Theory of the New Authoritarianism", NBER Working Paper No 21136.
  • Meyersson, Erik, and Dani Rodrik, "Erdogan's Coup", Foreign Affairs, May 26th, 2014,
  • Mukand, Sharun, and Dani Rodrik, 2016, "The Political Economy of Liberal Democracy",working paper.
  • Rodrik, Dani, 2014, "A General's Coup", mimeo.
  • Strömberg, David, 2015, "Media and Politics", Annual Review of Economics, 7: 173-205.

This policy brief is published on Forum for Research on Eastern Europe and Emerging Economies (FREE Network) Policy brief series. FREE Network is a joint initiative by seven think tanks - SITE (Stockholm), BEROC (Minsk), BICEPS (Riga), CEFIR (Moscow), CenEA (Szczecin), ISET (Tbilisi) and KSE (Kiev). Together, these research institutes form an extensive network of leading academic experts on economic issues in Central and Eastern Europe and the former Soviet Union. For more information please visit the website of FREE Network here.

Download the Policy brief "On the Timing of Turkey’s Authoritarian Turn" here or read it on SITE's Slideshare channel below.

On the Timing of Turkey’s Authoritarian Turn from Stockholm Institute of Transition Economics

STOCKHOLM INSTITUTE OF TRANSITION ECONOMICS

  • Home
  • About us
  • Events
  • News
  • People
  • Publications

Erik Meyersson

Erik Meyersson is Assistant Professor at the Stockholm Institute of Transition Economics (SITE), and holds a Ph.D. in Economics from the Institute for International Economic Studies (IIES) at Stockholm University. His main research areas are political economics and development.

Stockholm School of Economics | Box 6501 | SE-113 83 Stockholm | Phone: +46 8 736 90 00
Apsia
CEMS
EFMD
PIM Network
PRME